"From an animalistic perspective, the clearest source of all this distress [in humans], both physical and psychological, lies in the aforementioned violence needlessly perpetrated by our civilization on the ecology of the planet; only alleviating the latter will we be able to heal the former. (Abran 17)"
"Too much about elephants, in the end--reminds us of ourselves to dismiss out of hand this revolt they're currently staging against their own dismissal. And while our concern may ultimately be rooted in that most human of impulses--the preservation of our own self-image--the great paradox about this particular moment in our history with the elephants is that saving them will require finally getting past ourselves it will demand the ultimate act of deep, interspecies empathy. (Siebert 537)"
Both Siebert and Abram are trying to prove a point about a specific issue in their essays. Both of the quotes are claims, however with different approaches. In Siebert's quote, he mentions that humans have an impulse to preserve our species, whereas Abram states that the civilization needlessly perpetrated the violence. Abram is saying that humans are purposefully creating this dilemma and humans could have avoided this if they weren't so ignorant. Siebert explains that humans unknowingly created this issue because they are not aware of how to stop this problem from happening. He however gives an example of how humans can solve this issue.
No comments:
Post a Comment