"The other part of our newly emerging compact with elephants, however, is far more difficult to codify. It requires nothing less than a fundamental shift in the way we look at animals and, by extension ourselves. It requires what Bradshaw, somewhat whimsically, refers to as a new “trans-specie psyche”, a commitment to move beyond an anthropomorphic frame of reference and, in effect be elephants” (537)
Charles Siebert and elephant researchers Gay Bradshaw and Eve Abe suggest that it is not only not enough to be anthropomorphic when it comes to our understanding of elephants, they suggest quite its opposite: that we need to be elephants. Not only do we need to accord a degree of humanity to the elephants, we need to imbue our humanity with a degree of elephantness. What Siebert is asking us to do sounds impossible to achieve. How on earth do we become elephants? Yet, it does begin to make sense when we see that anthropomorphism is a call for sympathy. As highly social creatures, if elephants socialize, hurt and heal like humans then to accord them humanness is to say that we can begin to feel sympathy for them. The word sympathy is defined in the OED as “a real or virtual affinity or similarity between things”, it highlights the difference between the subjects that nonetheless share real or virtual points of similarity. Sympathy is only possible between unlike subjects, when we feel sympathy we feel it from a place of knowing that we are not in that spot of suffering, though we feel for those that are. Sympathy provides an escape from the situation. To resolve the elephant-human crisis anthropomorphic sympathy then is clearly only the first step. To move beyond it would be not just to feel sympathy but feel empathy. Empathy is defined in the OED as “The power of projecting one's personality into (and so fully comprehending) the object of contemplation.” Clearly, full comprehension of the object of contemplation, here the specie wide nervous breakdown of elephants, is not possible until the subject-object barrier is broken down by means of a personality projection that empathy allows. And so it is logical that Abe and Siebert think that we need to become elephants if we want to even understand the full scale of the problem. To be an elephant then is to cultivate a deep sense of empathy for creatures who, by the looks of it, look or feel nothing like us at all.
No comments:
Post a Comment