Monday, March 21, 2011

Relativity

One’s idea of wilderness can vary depending on one’s background and lifestyle. Due to the Alaskan territory that Chris McCandless lived on being only sixteen miles from a populated area, Krakauer reveals, “the wilderness surrounding the bus— the patch of overgrown country where McCandless was determined to ‘become lost in the wild’— scarcely qualifies as wilderness by Alaskan standards” (350). Most Alaskans would say the land McCandless lived on is not untamed or desolate enough to be wilderness, but Krakauer’s key phrase is “by Alaskan standards.” A standard is defined as typical or ordinary. Because these woods and brush surround Alaskans everyday, this land was typical and ordinary to them. These standards cannot apply to Chris because he was from a big city. Abram offers another example of wilderness being relative when he explains that shamans in rural countries can differentiate between the human standard and those of other animals. He explains that, while understand our own needs and capacities, “we cannot, as humans, precisely experience the living sensations of another form” (10). People know how they best survive, but do not have a full understanding of the way other species live, act, and think, so what is standard to other animals may be wilderness to humans. This inability to understand another form can also apply to humans, such as Chris, who was from a westernized city and did not understand the Alaskan lifestyle. Because the territory was wild enough to cost Chris his life, the standard for wilderness must be relative to each creature.

No comments:

Post a Comment